Picks & Plays for Monday, September 2
by David Aragona
View this card’s Highlight Horse and get TimeformUS PPs at Daily Racing Form.
PICKS
Race 1: 4 - 5 - 3 - 6
Race 2: 10 - 2 - 6 - 7
Race 3: 4 - 3 - 1 - 5
Race 4: 8 - 4 - 2 - 6
Race 5: 2 - 1 - 8 - 7
Race 6: 1 - 3 - 10 - 6
Race 7: 11 - 3 - 4 - 2
Race 8: 8 - 5 - 9 - 6
Race 9: 6 - 3 - 4 - 7
Race 10: 9 - 2 - 6 - 8
Race 11: 4 - 11 - 5 - 12
Race 12: 4 - 8 - 2 - 3
FAIR VALUE PLAYS
(Fair Value: These are the odds at which I could reasonably bet each of the horses listed. Wagering decisions should be based on the actual odds. The best value option will not necessarily be the top pick.)
RACE 8
Arzak (#5) ended his 2023 campaign in great form. He upset the field in the Woodford and then ran a lot better than the result would suggest in the Breeders' Cup when done in by a wide trip. He got back on track in the Shakertown this year and then was simply second best to division leader Cogburn in the G1 Jaipur. Horses have generally come back out of that race to flatter the form, which makes his odds-on loss in the Wolf Hill last time all the more disappointing. He just looked a little flat that day, and that raises some doubts coming into this spot. He’s the most accomplished member of this field, but figures to be a very short price. Main rival Souper Quest (#6) might be the “now” horse as he looks to win his first stakes for Mark Casse. It’s not as if he hasn’t faced good horses before, finishing third behind Breeders’ Cup winner Nobals in the Da Hoss last season. He’s lightly raced and appears to just be hitting his peak coming off that allowance win last time. However, I didn’t think he ran that much better than Our Shot (#9), who figures to be a bigger price. He lost his form this spring, but didn’t get the right trip in the Elusive Quality three back. His turf form prior to that had been good, and he just narrowly lost this race last season. Big Invasion (#8) finished just ahead of him that day, launching a late season campaign that ended with a narrow defeat in the Breeders’ Cup. He’s been unable to recapture that form since returning as a 5-year-old, but he’s also had a few excuses along the way. The trip really didn’t work out for him two back in the Jaipur, as he was too keen behind horses early and then had to steady and alter course in traffic in the stretch. He rebounded last time in a race that has proven to be pretty solid. Perhaps some will jump off the bandwagon, but I think he might be rounding back into form, and we know he loves this 5 1/2 furlong distance at Saratoga.
Fair Value:
#8 BIG INVASION, at 4-1 or greater
RACE 9
Chad Brown sends out two of the likely favorites, who hit the wire together in a conditioned claiming race back in July. It’s Hot In Here (#4) was the winner that day after getting a very nice ride from Irad Ortiz. She sat off a hot pace set by a runaway leader, and saved ground every step of the way while making a rally up the rail. However, I would argue that stablemate Dea Matrona (#6) might have put forth the better effort in defeat. She was in a tough position, chasing two rivals who had run clear of the field on the front end, making her the leader of the main pack without any cover. She then had to make the first move into that hot pace while going wider on the far turn, and she still dug in gamely to just miss. I also thought her race two back was better than it looks, as she attempted to make a wide run around the far turn in a race dominated by a vastly superior stablemate. I’m viewing her as the horse to beat in this spot, and she is my top pick. The other horse I want to consider is Surprenant Cocca (#3), who makes her first start off the claim for Mike Maker. While Maker doesn’t have stellar statistics off the claim in general, he is 9 for 47 (19%, $2.04 ROI) off the claim with horses moving up into allowance turf routes over 5 years. This filly ran a race back in May that would make her awfully tough against a field like this. She didn’t perform at all next time at Delaware, but some horses don’t handle that turf course. She rebounded with a much better performance last time, and might have been seriously involved in the finish if she hadn’t gotten such a passive ride. Now she gets the more aggressive Luis Saez on board as Maker also applies blinkers. It was a close call for me between she and Dea Matrona, and I basically want to bet whichever of these deviates higher from my fair odds.
Fair Value:
#6 DEA MATRONA, at 5-2 or greater
#3 SURPRENANT COCCA, at 5-1 or greater
RACE 10
I’m hardly against likely favorite Ferocious (#2) in this Hopeful. The $1.3 million auction purchase ran to that price tag and then some on debut, delivering the kind of performance that gets racing fans dreaming about the future. He didn’t break that sharply, but quickly got himself into position, traveling strongly throughout. Yet the most impressive part of the race came when Javier Castellano pushed the button. This colt lengthened his stride in a manner you rarely see from 2-year-olds, clocking a final eighth in 11.86 seconds. There have been a couple of runbacks from the race, neither remarkable. Gustavo Delgado is 0 for 8 with last-out debut winners making their second starts over 5 years, but I’m not getting overly concerned with stats. This is a pretty strong Hopeful field that includes other impressive debut winners, but Ferocious gives off the vibe of something special. There does appear to be ample early speed in this race, and I have respect for Studlydoright (#6), who might get unfairly dismissed despite being the most accomplished runner in this field. While he did earn a stakes victory in the Tremont, that race hasn’t proven to be the strongest over time, and I thought he was supposed to get the job done last time in the Sanford, though he was hitting his best stride late. Like Ferocious, he’s got this massive stride that suggests he should prefer added ground. I expect him to be running on late and I want to use him in exactas and trifectas, but I wonder if a victory might be just out of reach. Both Chad Brown runners look like they could be the main rivals to the favorite. Chancer McPatrick (#8) will take more money off his eye-catching last-to-first debut victory. He had to steady a bit early in that race while reacting to kickback, but was absolutely flying home once steered into the clear. This horse appears to have talent, but I am somewhat bothered by the fact that a few runbacks from that race have been disappointing. It does appear to be a day where the dirt sprints as a group may have been tricky for figuermakers. I prefer Chad’s other horse Incentive Pay (#9). He didn’t create quite as much buzz after his debut victory earlier in the meet, which earned a more modest 91 TimeformUS Speed Figure. The fourth-place finisher Filoso did come back to win going a mile this week, and runner-up Dapper Moon came back to win impressively against a strong field on Saturday. Incentive Pay also didn’t have a perfect trip in victory, as he got briefly shuffled in traffic approaching the half-mile pole before making a sustained rally inside. He’s continued to train well out of the debut, and he has some dam’s side pedigree to stretch out, with the dam being a half-sister to dirt route stakes winner Mo Cuishle. He, of course, isn't as likely to win as Ferocious, but he is going to be a more playable price, and 2-year-olds can get a lot faster between their first and second starts.
Fair Value:
#9 INCENTIVE PAY, at 9-2 or greater
RACE 11
The penultimate race of this 2024 Saratoga season is one of the most intriguing affairs of the entire meet. There is a pretty solid favorite in Child of the Moon (#11), who made a favorable impression in her U.S. debut for Chad Brown. She had shown some hints of talent overseas, and appeared to take a step forward in her stateside debut last time. That race featured a very slow early pace, and she was closing best of all late to just miss. However, now she’s landing in a deeper field and was done no favors by drawing so far outside. I do prefer her to Brown’s other entrant Venencia (#8), who was plagued by gate issues in both starts for the barn last season. I’m not convinced about her overall talent, and she likely needs a pace collapse to be effective. There is ample speed in here, as indicated by the fast pace designation on the TimeformUS Pace Projector. That could work against one of several horses trying the turf for the first time. Sugar Hi (#2) has been working very well ahead of her grass debut, including a couple of impressive drills over the Oklahoma turf course. However, she has to prove she can get this added distance in a race featuring other speed. Another first time turfer in a similar situation is Mystifying (#5), but I have a little more faith in her adapting to new tactics. This daughter of Curlin has plenty of Phipps turf pedigree in her female family, and has also worked well on the surface ahead of this start. Shug McGaughey also has strong statistics coming off layoffs in turf routes. Given all the speed signed on, I’m expecting an honest pace setup for the closers. The late runner who interests me most is Golden Rocket (#4), who makes her second start off a layoff for new trainer Charlton Baker. She’s not a natural turf sprinter, but she actually ran pretty well cutting back to 5 1/2 furlongs off the layoff last time in her first start for the new barn. She traveled well into the race and briefly looked like a winner in upper stretch before flattening out late. She should benefit from getting that race under her belt as she now stretches back out to her preferred route distance. She’s drawn well and should work out a ground-saving trip under Jose Lezcano. With two Chad Brown runners and a few appealing surface switchers in the mix, she seems like the kind of horse who could get a little forgotten on the tote board.
Fair Value:
#4 GOLDEN ROCKET, at 6-1 or greater